Casey’s Custom Cookies

Hello and thank you for visiting my shop, it truly means so much to me. I know that you could have chosen from hundreds of other bakers, so it is really an honor to have you here. ❤️

I am a momma of three 🧔‍♂️👩🏻🧔‍♂️ a Grandma of seven 👩🏻🧒👩🏻🧒👧🏻👦🏻👶 a dog mom to two 🐕‍🦺🦮 and a cookier👩‍🍳 who loves to bake and decorate sugar cookies and other fun treats. Let me help you make your next event (or just any old day) special!

My Decorated Sugar Cookies start at $48/dozen which includes one cookie flavor choice per dozen, or you can add a second flavor choice for an additional $5. All cookies are decorated with Vanilla Royal Icing except Red Velvet which is decorated with Cream Cheese Royal Icing. *Pricing varies on design complexity.

Please note, if you choose a cookie with a narrow design, especially when connected to a wider area, be aware that they will be very fragile and break easily because of the soft bake on the cookie.

I also offer cake pops which come “flat/puck” style and start at $35/dozen or $3.50/pop which includes one cake flavor per dozen. All cake pops are dipped in almond bark and decorated as agreed upon. *Pricing varies on design complexity.

Hot Cocoa Bombs used to be just for the fall and winter months but this past year it was popular year round! I offer a variety of flavors priced from $5-$7 per large delicious bomb!!

I am grateful for all orders and put many hours into the planning, design, creating, baking, decorating, and packaging of your cookies. I do my best to make sure that you know that I put my all into every order and that every customer is important to me. I appreciate you trusting me to help make your day special.

Because I have more than one order going at a time I appreciate a two week lead time for a typical order under three dozen. Anything from three to five dozen please allow three weeks and over five dozen please allow four weeks or more.

A non-refundable 50% deposit is due within 48 hours of the placement of the order. Final payment is due 48 hours before pickup.

I accept Venmo, Apple Pay, Cash App, Google Pay, or Zelle