Thanksgiving Cake Collection
Thanksgiving Cake Collection 🍂 Celebrate Thanksgiving with a handcrafted, gluten-free cake from Caitlyn's Cakes! Choose from four specialty flavors: 🍁 Chocolate Chai Caramel Espresso Rich chocolate cake with chai-spiced caramel filling and espresso buttercream. 🍁 Cranberry Orange Lemon Lemon cake with cranberry-orange compote and brown sugar buttercream. 🍁 Chocolate Cream Pie Cookies & cream cake with chocolate pudding ganache and toasted marshmallow buttercream. 🍁 Cherry Almond Pie Vanilla-almond cake with cherry compote and almond buttercream. Available in 6-inch, two-layer cakes. Limited quantities available. Preorder required. Pick up will be Nov 25th @ 3pm or later.
$75.00
click for description
Tiered Cakes — Signature Collection
Tiered Cakes — Signature Collection Elegant, elevated, and uniquely yours. All tiered cakes are part of our Signature Collection, regardless of design complexity. Each cake includes a personalized digital design mockup, with up to two revisions for collaborative adjustments within the original design concept. Mockups are provided 7 days before pickup, with feedback requested within 48 hours. Caitlyn's Cakes retains creative control over the final design. Tiered Cake Sizes & Starting Prices Two Tiers - 4" + 6" — Serves ~20 — Starting at $200 - 6" + 8" — Serves ~40 — Starting at $260 - 8" + 10" — Serves ~64 — Starting at $384 Three Tiers - 4" + 6" + 8" — Serves ~46 — Starting at $350 - 6" + 8" + 10" — Serves ~78 — Starting at $468 Serving sizes are approximate and may vary based on how the cake is cut. Starting prices reflect tiered cake construction and the Signature design experience. Final pricing varies based on design details, specialty decorations, and overall complexity. Custom materials may incur additional charges.
Starting at $200.00
click for description
Cupcakes
$3.50 starting price each, price can change based on design. Minimum order of 1 dozen. Sold in increments of twelve.
Starting at $42.00
click for description
6 Inch Cake [Serves 10-14]
3 layer, 6 inch round
Starting at $95.00
click for description
Why Caitlyn’s Cakes?
Custom gluten-free cakes made in Chico, CA
Hi! I’m Caitlyn, the celiac baker behind Caitlyn’s Cakes. I specialize in custom gluten-free cakes and treats made from scratch in my home kitchen in Chico, CA.
Whether you’re celebrating a birthday, shower, or special occasion, I focus on flavors that feel nostalgic, comforting, and just as good (or better 👀) as traditional baked goods, without the gluten.
Starting prices are shown with each item — just tell me your budget and vision!
A deposit secures your date, with the balance due before pickup.
Limited custom orders accepted each week — booking 2–6 weeks in advance.
1. Submit your request with date + details
2. I confirm availability & pricing with Invoice
3. Deposit secures your spot
On select Saturdays (every other week), I offer a limited Grab & Go menu with fresh, ready-to-pick-up gluten-free treats. These menus are announced on social media and often sell out quickly.
👉 Follow along on Instagram & Facebook (icons linked at the bottom of this page) for upcoming Grab & Go menus and dates.
Delivery is available for a fee in the Chico area with an order of $100 or more.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
“Delicious, great variety, and celiac safe. I’m so grateful we have a gluten-free bakery in town!”
— Alice, Chico (Facebook)
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
“I didn’t know gluten-free could be so good — absolutely wonderful cupcakes, and I can’t wait to try more baked goods next time.”
— Casey, Chico (Google)
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
“All the cupcakes I’ve had have been so delicious — the chocolate peanut butter was amazing. I also tried the chocolate raspberry cake, and it was one of the best cakes I’ve ever tasted. So glad I found Caitlyn’s Cakes!”
— Nick, Chico (Facebook)
A non-refundable deposit is required to secure your custom order date. Orders are not considered booked until the deposit has been received.
Final pricing is confirmed after reviewing order details. The remaining balance is due 7 days prior to pickup, unless otherwise noted.
Custom orders placed with less than 3 days’ notice are subject to a 5% rush fee and require full payment at booking.
Rush fees do not apply to Grab & Go items or Specials.